Sex Toys for Adults: The Honest Buying Guide

Sex Toys for Adults: The Honest Buying Guide

Sex Toys for Adults: The Honest Buying Guide

Buying Guides

A sex toy is any object made to create or intensify sexual pleasure, from a $15 bullet vibrator to a $200 app-controlled couples toy, and the right one depends on your body, your goal, and how much noise and mess you're willing to deal with. I spent six years selling these across a counter, and the question I heard more than any other wasn't "which one is best." It was "which one is right for me." Those are two different questions. This guide answers the second one.

How to choose
Pick Your First Toy in Three Steps
01
Know your goal
External clitoral stimulation, internal fullness, or anal play each call for a different shape.
02
Check the material
Stick to silicone, glass, or stainless steel; skip jelly or vague 'skin-safe' blends with no ingredient list.
03
Match the power source
Rechargeable for frequent use, battery for a cheap backup, app or remote only if a partner's involved.

What Actually Counts as a Sex Toy

If it's designed to create or amplify sexual sensation, it's a toy. That covers a lot more ground than most people expect walking in the door:

  • Vibrators, for external stimulation, usually clitoral
  • Dildos, for penetration with no motor, controlled entirely by hand or harness
  • Rabbits, which combine internal and external stimulation in one toy
  • Masturbators, sleeves and strokers built for a penis
  • Anal toys, plugs, beads, and prostate stimulators shaped for safe anal play
  • Couples toys, remote or app-controlled pieces meant to be used with a partner in the room or across the country
  • Fetish and bondage gear, restraints, impact toys, and clothing that play with sensation and power rather than direct stimulation

Solo use and partnered use are not separate categories of toy, they're separate uses of the same toy. A vibrator doesn't become a "couples toy" just because two people are in the room.

Four Questions to Ask Before You Buy Anything

Every return I ever processed traced back to one of these four questions never getting asked.

What's the actual goal?

External clitoral stimulation, internal fullness, G-spot pressure, anal fullness, and penis stimulation all need a different shape. A toy built for one does the others badly. If you're not sure which you want, start with the one you already know you like from sex with a partner or your own hand, and buy a toy that does that better, not a toy that tries to do everything.

What does your body actually respond to?

Clitoral sensitivity varies enormously. Some people need direct contact and strong vibration, some find that uncomfortable within seconds and prefer broad, indirect pressure. If you've never used a toy before, buy on the gentler end of the power range. You can always turn it up. You can't turn a toy that's too intense back into a toy you enjoy.

What's the power source and how loud is it really?

Motors come in two flavors: rumbly (lower frequency, felt deeper, generally quieter) and buzzy (higher frequency, felt more on the surface, generally louder and higher pitched). A buzzy toy on its highest setting is audible through a closed bedroom door. A rumbly toy at the same setting is not. Rechargeable toys last longer per charge, cost more up front, and die for good eventually. Battery-powered toys are cheaper and the battery is replaceable forever, but you will own more AAAs than you'd like.

What's the budget, and does the material match it?

Fifteen dollars and two hundred dollars can both buy you a good toy. They cannot both buy you a toy with ten vibration patterns, a waterproof rating, and medical-grade silicone. Decide which of those three actually matters to you before you look at price.

The Main Categories, Compared

This is the breakdown I used to sketch on a notepad for customers who'd been standing in front of the wall for ten minutes.

Category Best for Typical price Noise level
Vibrators External clitoral stimulation, fastest learning curve $15-$90 Quiet to moderate
Dildos Penetration, full control over angle and pace $20-$80 Silent, no motor
Rabbit vibrators Internal and external stimulation together $40-$120 Moderate to loud
Masturbators Penis stimulation, hands-free or hands-on $20-$100 Quiet to moderate
Prostate stimulators Anal and prostate play, often paired with external arm $30-$110 Quiet to moderate

Notice price and quality don't move in a straight line. A $90 vibrator from a brand that invests in a good motor beats a $90 vibrator from a brand that spent the money on a flashy box.

Material Matters More Than the Brand Name on the Box

This is the part I actually cared about on the sales floor, because it's the part that affects your health, not just your experience.

  • Body-safe and non-porous: medical-grade silicone, borosilicate glass, and stainless steel. These don't harbor bacteria in surface pores, they can be fully cleaned, and they don't leach anything into your skin over time.
  • Porous and best avoided for anything that goes near a mucous membrane: "jelly," rubber, and vague "skin-safe" blends with no listed ingredients. Porous material can trap bacteria even after washing, and it's where phthalates most often show up. If a listing can't tell you what the toy is actually made of, that's a red flag, not a technicality.
  • Shared use: if a toy is going between partners or between orifices, either switch to a fresh condom on it each time or pick non-porous material you can fully disinfect between uses.

Lube belongs in this conversation too. Silicone toys and silicone-based lube don't always get along, the lube can degrade the toy's surface over time. Water-based lube is the safe default for silicone toys; check our lubes if you're not sure which bottle on your shelf is which.

Mistakes First-Timers Make, in Order of How Often I Saw Them

  1. Buying the toy that looked most impressive instead of the one shaped for their actual goal. The biggest, loudest, most feature-packed toy on the wall is rarely the one that gets used after the first week.
  2. Going straight to maximum intensity. Start low. A toy that feels like nothing at setting one might feel like plenty at setting three.
  3. Skipping lube entirely. Even with natural arousal, added lube reduces friction on both skin and toy surface and makes everything feel better, not just possible.
  4. Ignoring battery type until the toy dies mid-use. Check whether it's rechargeable or battery-powered before you buy, not after.
  5. Jumping into bondage or impact gear without a conversation about limits first. Beginner-friendly restraints exist, but the gear is never a substitute for talking about limits out loud first.

Care and Cleaning, the Short Version

  • Wash non-electronic silicone, glass, and steel toys with warm water and mild soap, or a dedicated toy cleaner, before and after every use.
  • For toys with a motor, check the waterproof rating before submerging anything. "Splash-proof" and "waterproof" are not the same claim.
  • Let toys dry fully before storing them touching each other, silicone against silicone can degrade over time.
  • Remove batteries from toys you're not using for a while. A leaked battery ruins more toys than rough use ever does.

Discretion, Because It's the Real Reason Half of You Are Reading This Online

Everything ships in plain packaging with no logos, and the charge on your statement shows a neutral billing descriptor, not the store name. That was the single most-asked question at the counter when I worked retail, and it's the one thing online shopping solves better than any store ever could.

Where to Start, Based on What You Already Know

If you've never owned a toy, start with one category and one goal. A simple external vibrator or a straightforward dildo will teach you more about what you actually like than any combo toy will on day one, you're isolating one variable instead of three. If you already know your anatomy and want to build out a drawer, a two or three piece starter kit is priced to let you try several shapes at once instead of guessing wrong one purchase at a time.

FAQ

Are sex toys safe to use every day?

Yes, for most people, as long as the toy is non-porous, cleaned between uses, and you're not using it on irritated or broken skin. Daily use doesn't desensitize you long-term, that's a myth left over from decades of bad sex ed.

What's the difference between a vibrator and a dildo?

A vibrator has a motor and is usually built for external stimulation, though some are shaped for penetration too. A dildo has no motor and is built purely for penetration, with the user controlling all the motion by hand or with a harness.

Do I need lube with every toy?

You don't strictly need it with every toy, but it makes nearly every toy feel better and reduces friction that can irritate skin over repeated use. Use water-based lube with silicone toys specifically, since silicone-based lube can degrade silicone material over time.

How do I clean a vibrator that has a motor?

Wipe it down with a dedicated toy cleaner or mild soap on a damp cloth, focusing on any seams. Only submerge it if the listing specifically says waterproof, not just splash-proof, and never submerge the charging port.

Can couples use sex toys together without it meaning something is missing from the relationship?

Yes, and this is the most common misconception I ran into on the floor. A toy adds a sensation neither partner can create alone, the same way a new restaurant doesn't mean your kitchen is broken.

What's the best sex toy for a total beginner?

A simple, rumbly external vibrator with two or three speed settings, nothing with a dozen patterns you'll never use. Get familiar with what intensity and rhythm you actually like before paying for complexity.

About Ashley Bloom

Ashley Bloom spent six years on the shop floor of an adult store, which means she has had the awkward conversation a few thousand times and knows which questions people are really asking. She now buys for My Secret and writes the guides, which puts her in the unusual position of knowing both what sells and what quietly comes back. She would rather talk you out of a bad purchase than sell you an expensive one.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.